Relax at Main Street Motel in Fish Creek, WI. Enjoy laid-back rooms with free Wi-Fi, minifridges, and easy access to Peninsula State Park and Sunset Beach.
Visitors appreciate the motel’s spotless rooms, convenient downtown setting, and attentive, friendly staff that enhance their Door County experience.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Main Street Motel offers straightforward, comfortable accommodations with practical amenities such as minifridges, flat-screen TVs, and complimentary Wi-Fi. The motel maintains a clean and well-kept environment, which guests frequently note, highlighting the attentive care given by the owners and staff. Its low-rise, seasonal operation suits travelers seeking a relaxed, no-frills option in Fish Creek.
Situated just a short four-minute stroll from Sunset Beach Park and conveniently close to Peninsula State Park, this location provides easy access to several local attractions. Nearby outdoor activities include biking, golfing, and visiting historical sites like Eagle Bluff Lighthouse. The property's quiet setting, combined with its proximity to shops, restaurants, and waterfront views, appeals to visitors looking to explore Door County on foot.
The motel welcomes an inclusive crowd and is particularly noted for being LGBTQ+ friendly. Reviews praise the friendly and accommodating staff, with several guests mentioning smooth check-ins and helpful service, including personal touches for special occasions. While some praise its cleanliness and inviting atmosphere, a few remarks suggest that some decor features may feel dated, and room amenities are basic, reflecting the motel’s modest style.
For those traveling by air, Main Street Motel is accessible from Green Bay Austin Straubel International Airport, approximately an hour and twenty minutes away by car. Several nearby accommodations offer alternatives ranging from similarly rated lodgings to higher-end inns, all within a short distance. Overall, this property suits travelers seeking a practical, well-maintained base for exploring the natural and cultural highlights of Fish Creek and the surrounding area.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Wonderful, clean, great location - our go-to for the perfect Door County getaway.
Clean quaint rooms. Friendly staff. Great location!
Agree with reviewer John: this property is PRISTINE, not a spider web nor chipped paint in sight. You can tell the owners take exceptional care and are invested in your comfort. The Main Street Motel is so inviting, perfectly situated in downtown Fish Creek, and great value overall. Highly recommend.
My daughter and I decided to visit Door County and visit local wineries for my birthday. This motel was recommended by a co-worker, and her high opinion of this establishment is well deserved. I had some questions prior to making the reservation, and while speaking with staff they were more than friendly. Check in went very smooth, and the desk clerk was pleasant, well-informed and charming. The room was incredibly clean and the decor was quite nice. The beds were pretty comfortable, and room accommodations were perfect for us. During our stay we had an unfortunate event, and I had to reach out to the owner (Debbie) very late Friday night. She was highly accommodating, compassionate and helpful. I have not stayed at any other establishments in Fish Creek, so I really have no comparison. In my opinion a 5/5 rating is not sufficient. I feel this motel is second to none. Make your reservations here, you won't regret it! (P.S. I wrote this review prior to check-out due to the impressive service provided by all.) Edit: The 'desk clerk' I mentioned is the owner! (I didn't realize because of masks.) Simply put; Debbie is a super person. Enjoy your stay!
Excellent location. Very pleasant staff. Room was very clean, decor was pretty dated—zebra, leopard, cheetah, tiger printed rooster wallpaper was peeling—tv was tiny and mattress could have been more comfortable. Beautiful “courtyard” garden flowers. Lots of parking. Everything in Door county seems pretty pricey for what it is and this was no exception. Would recommend for a place in town in walking distance to waterfront to watch the sunset, the harbour, restaurants, shops, parks, etc.
The location of this hotel can't be beat. The room was very clean and quiet and for the weekend we were there (Labor Day), it was an incredible value. We were able to walk to many restaurants which was great given parking is tough in the area.
We love staying here . It's a nice room and a block from Sunset beach. It's walking distance to the shops and restaurants in Fish Creek. We stayed here for our Anniversary and they helped surprise me with flowers my husband ordered for me from Blossoms flower shop.
This place is the cleanest, most well maintained motel we have ever stayed in, in Fish Creek WI. The grounds are full of beautiful flowers! It is within walking distance of food, shops, a small beach, and Sunset Beach- to actually watch the sunset. Staff is friendly and helpful. Off street free parking in back of building. Handicap accessible.
Perfect for couples or friends traveling together. We had a girls weekend—motel room was very clean, had a mini fridge, microwave and coffee maker. Excellent water pressure and heat in the shower. There’s a nice outdoor area where you can sit and read or visit while looking at the cliffs. A total steal.
Charming, clean, and conveniently located in downtown Fish Creek. Its within walking distance to everything you want to do in FC. Very nice staff and we had a great experience!
A 4-minute walk from Sunset Beach Park, this seasonal, low-rise motel is 0.6 miles from Peninsula State Park and 7 miles from Mud Lake State Natural Area.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
5,576 reviews 9462 Shore Rd, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States
1 reviews 9197 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States
973 reviews 10249 Shore Rd, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Hillside Motel, a 4.1star LGBTQ+ friendly lodging in Lake George, NY. Close to Fort William Henry, Six Flags Great Escape...
Casual motel on Queens Blvd offering free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms. Near subway, 5 miles from LaGuardia Airport, and...
Stay at Magnolia Inn in Hattiesburg, MS with free WiFi, breakfast, and parking. Close to Hattiesburg Zoo and museums. 3star hote...
Relax Inn Motel in West Babylon, NY offers 3.5star comfort with free WiFi and parking. Close to Adventureland, Robert Moses Stat...
Stay at Crest Motel, a 3.1star motel located at 2545 S Lincoln Ave, Jerome, ID. Close to Shoshone Falls Park and Perrine Memorial...
Country Inn offers free WiFi, parking, pool, and hot tub in Hancock, MA. Nearby attractions include Jiminy Peak and Clark Art Ins...
Stay at Oasis Motel in Bronx, NY. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, and easy access to Yankee Stadium, Bronx Zoo & New York Botanical Gar...
Contemporary extendedstay hotel in Columbus, GA offering fully equipped kitchens, free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and convenient ...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
